As requested, here’s the top 100 in one handy-dandy place, with links to appropriate posts. Because we love you, we’ve also included numbers 101-150 as well. Debate! Argue! Just don’t hurt one another!!
1) Stankonia | OutKast
2) Phrenology | The Roots
3) Back To Black | Amy Winehouse
4) Songs For The Deaf | Queens of the Stone Age
5) In Rainbows | Radiohead
6) Be | Common
7) American Idiot | Green Day
8) The Blueprint | Jay-Z
9) Sea Change | Beck
10) Late Registration | Kanye West
11) Graduation | Kanye West
12) Parachutes | Coldplay
13) Game Theory | The Roots
14) The Black Album | Jay-Z
15) Morning View | Incubus
16) Rockin’ The Suburbs | Ben Folds
17) Toxicity | System of a Down
18) St. Elsewhere | Gnarls Barkley
19) Elephant | The White Stripes
20) The Bravery | The Bravery
21) Black Holes & Revelations | Muse
22) Heavier Things | John Mayer
23) The College Dropout | Kanye West
24) For Emma, Forever Ago | Bon Iver
25) Comin’ From Where I’m From | Anthony Hamilton
26) Relationship of Command | At The Drive-In
27) Illinoise | Sufjan Stevens
28) Oracular Spectacular | MGMT
29) Viva La Vida Or Death And All His Friends | Coldplay
30) Rated R | Queens of the Stone Age
31) Funeral | The Arcade Fire
32) Silent Alarm | Bloc Party
33) Audioslave | Audioslave
34) Extraordinary Machine | Fiona Apple
35) Wonder What’s Next | Chevelle
36) Hip-Hop Is Dead | Nas
37) Up | Peter Gabriel
38) How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb | U2
39) O | Damien Rice
40) Continuum | John Mayer
41) Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots | The Flaming Lips
42) Quality Control | Jurassic 5
43) Plans | Death Cab For Cutie
44) Jane Doe | Converge
45) Once Again | John Legend
46) Year of the Gentleman | Ne-Yo
47) () | Sigur Ros
48) Boys & Girls In America | The Hold Steady
49) Get Behind Me Satan | The White Stripes
50) White Blood Cells | The White Stripes
51) Like Water For Chocolate | Common
52) Fleet Foxes | Fleet Foxes
53) Absolution | Muse
54) Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga | Spoon
55) Is This It? |The Strokes
56) The Photo Album | Death Cab for Cutie
57) The Marshall Mathers LP | Eminem
58) Z | My Morning Jacket
59) White Pony | Deftones
60) Quality | Talib Kweli
61) Yankee Hotel Foxtrot| Wilco
62) Fever To Tell | Yeah Yeah Yeahs
63) Demon Days | Gorillaz
64) Twentysomething | Jamie Cullum
65) The Eminem Show | Eminem
66) Room For Squares | John Mayer
67) Speakerboxx/The Love Below | OutKast
68) Kid A | Radiohead
69) Speak For Yourself | Imogen Heap
70) Bleed American (Jimmy Eat World) | Jimmy Eat World
71) On The Jungle Floor | Van Hunt
72) Source Tags & Codes | …and You Will Know Us By The Trail of the Dead
73) Fever Ray | Fever Ray
74) Lateralus | Tool
75) 13 Ways To Bleed On Stage | Cold
76) Donuts | J. Dilla
77) Leviathan | Mastodon
78) Turn On The Bright Lights | Interpol
79) Rock Steady | No Doubt
80) Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea | PJ Harvey
81) The Private Press | DJ Shadow
82) Attack And Release | The Black Keys
83) Stage Names | Okkervil River
84) Hearts Of Oak | Ted Leo & The Pharmacists
85) Nia | Blackalicious
86) Antics | Interpol
87) Begin To Hope | Regina Spektor
88) Hail To The Thief | Radiohead
89) The Dirty South | The Drive-By Truckers
90) Mesmerize/Hypnotize | System of a Down
91) Ashes Of The Wake | Lamb Of God
92) Black Gives Way To Blue | Alice in Chains
93) Cease To Begin | Band of Horses
94) 19 | Adele
95) Light Grenades | Incubus
96) 100th Window | Massive Attack
97) Wolfmother | Wolfmother
98) At War With The Mystics | The Flaming Lips
99) Hot Fuss | The Killers
100) The Tipping Point | The Roots
…and here are the albums that would have placed 101-150, if we’d extended the list that far (in order from highest voted to lowest.)
Songs In A Minor | Alicia Keys
Fantasies | Metric
Only By The Night | Kings of Leon
Consolers of the Lonely | The Raconteurs
And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out | Yo La Tengo
Lullabies To Paralyze | Queens of the Stone Age
Give Up | The Postal Service
Return To Cookie Mountain | TV On The Radio
LCD Soundsystem | LCD Soundsystem
The Renaissance | Q-Tip
All That You Can’t Leave Behind | U2
Confessions | Usher
X&Y | C0ldplay
Welcome Interstate Managers | Fountains of Wayne
FutureSex/LoveSounds | Justin Timberlake
Instant Vintage | Raphael Saadiq
Rainbow Arabia | The Basta
A Rush of Blood to the Head | Coldplay
Lovers’ Rock | Sade
Vampire Weekend | Vampire Weekend
Mirrored | Battles
Magic | Bruce Springsteen
Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace | Foo Fighters
I And Love And You | The Avett Brothers
Bubblegum | Mark Lanegan
Ain’t Nobody Worryin’ | Anthony Hamilton
The Undisputed Truth | Brother Ali
A Beautiful World | Thicke
808s & Heartbreak | Kanye West
A Time 2 Love | Stevie Wonder
Sing The Sorrow | AFI
Electric Version | The New Pornographers
Stadium Arcadium | Red Hot Chili Peppers
Original Pirate Material | The Streets
White People | Handsome Boy Modeling School
The Grind Date | De La Soul
Supernature | Goldfrapp
The Shepherd’s Dog | Iron & Wine
Multiply | Jamie Lidell
Cookie: The Anthropological Mixtape | Meshell Ndegeocello
A Beautiful Lie | 30 Seconds To Mars
Madvillainy | Madvillain
Franz Ferdinand | Franz Ferdinand
Sumday | Grandaddy
Origin of Symmetry | Muse
Sleeping With Ghosts | Placebo
In Absentia | Porcupine Tree
Discovery | Daft Punk
Welcoming Home The Astronauts | Flickerstick
Fishscale | Ghostface Killah