A couple weeks back, I explained how much I loved Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes’ 1976 classic “Wake Up Everybody”, and I treated you to the new remake by John Legend & the Roots featuring Melanie Fiona and Common (whew, that was a mouthful). Well, guess what folks? There’s a video now. Siting and watching the video (and listening to the song) has me filled with conflicting emotions. First is that I’m really looking forward to Legend & The Roots’ album-length collaboration “Wake Up” (scheduled to arrive later this year), and second is that as much as I enjoy The Roots (who’ve made one of 2010’s best albums), Legend (who’s consistent each time), and even Fiona (a bright newcomer) and Common (who appears to be headed back to his peak-era form, vocally and sartorially), the four acts combined can’t hold a candle to Teddy Pendergrass on the original. Legend’s too mannered a vocalist to take you to church the way T.P. did on the original, and the appearance of Fiona on the song doesn’t seem to serve much of a purpose.
Nevertheless, the message of the song is always welcome no matter who’s delivering it. Rock with the video and make sure you go back and get your hands on the original while you’re at it.
6 comments
carlos says:
Aug 20, 2010
Written by McFadden, Whitehead & Carstarphen… produced by Gamble & Huff… Teddy on the mic… this song is Mount Rushmore type shit. You CAN’T improve on that!
blerd says:
Aug 20, 2010
I absolutely agree. The remake isn’t bad, but some songs should be left alone!
GG says:
Aug 20, 2010
You guys are totally right, but I’m still looking forward to this release. I don’t think they should try to improve the originals as much as spin them a bit.
blerd says:
Aug 21, 2010
They can spin them, sure. But this is more or less a Xerox.
GG says:
Aug 21, 2010
How can you Xerox the song with a female voice and a rapper? Just because the music sounds similar?
blerd says:
Aug 21, 2010
The gender of the voice doesn’t really make a difference. It’s still the same melody, same cadence, and the instrumentation sounds fairly identical as well (just modernized). Common’s part is the only thing about the song that gives it any individuality-and I don’t know how integral it is to the song itself. I’m not mad at them for covering it, I just think it’s unnecessary.