Sorry for a bit of a break from the countdown, I was taking care of some business in my old stomping grounds and hip-hop’s birthplace. I hope you’ve been enjoying the series so far. Check out past entries that you may have missed:
15. Ghostface Killah
Representing: Staten Island
Can you name anything good that has come out of Staten Island other than the Wu-Tang Clan? Consider the fact that I lived in New York City for almost thirty years and the only event of distinction I can claim from my time in that borough is that it’s the one and only place I’ve ever been in a car that was pulled over for DWB (AKA Driving While Black). Damn-thank God for the Wu. And I bet the Wu thanks God for Ghostface. If you’re the standout member of a group that contains lyrical giants like ODB, GZA, Raekwon and Method Man (who’s one of the illest dudes on the mic when he feels like it), then you’ve obviously got something special. Ghostface can battle rhyme, he can be funny, he can tug at the heartstrings, he’s the complete package. He has yet to make a below-average album (something NO one else in the Wu can claim), and quiet as kept, Apollo Kids was one of last year’s best hip-hop albums (although Def Jam did a shitty job promoting it). All hail the Wallabee Champ-MVP of Wu-Tang.
14. Cee-Lo
Representing: Atlanta
Fuck “Fuck You” (actually, don’t…I really fucking like that song). Cee-Lo has been blessed with an overabundance of gifts. He can write a mean song (do y’all know that he wrote “Don’t ‘Cha” for the Pussycat Dolls?), he can sing his ass off, and something that may have been forgotten in light of his Gnarls Barkley and recent solo success is that the man can spit better than just about anyone else period. Not only did he sartorially and musically influence Andre 3000 (in one of those cases where the student passes the teacher, similar to Jackie Wilson vs. Michael Jackson), but it’s not hard to imagine that ‘Lo had an influence on young Andre’s rhyme style too. You don’t think Cee-Lo can rhyme? Click on the clip below and reconsider, my friend.
Representing: Brick City (Newark, NJ)
Yet another guy who doesn’t get his props as a legend. Red was easily the best rhymer to come out of the whole Def Squad/Hit Squad group (and neither K-Solo nor Keith Murray was exactly what you’d call a slouch). Much like other rappers in this group of five, he’s extremely versatile, with absolutely killer punchlines. If you looked up the Top “Oh, Shit-I Can’t Believe He Said That!” emcees, he’d probably be Top Five. He also has the ability to take things that you would normally consider average (Def Squad compilation albums, movies with Method Man, Christina Aguilera singles) and make them ten times better. I wish I knew why the hell he takes so long between albums (not sure if it’s Def Jam bullshit or all that weed he smokes), but whether he’s putting albums out at an accelerated pace or dropping a new joint every four years, Reggie Noble is still and always will be the shit.
12. Black Thought
Representing: Philadelphia
Let’s give it up for Tariq Trotter. As a vital cog in hip-hop’s longest lasting band (hell, these days they’re hip-hop’s only band), Black Thought has put together a streak of consistency that rivals anyone in his genre’s. From the early days of The Roots (when they were doing the acid jazz thing and no one was really sure what to do with them) to now, when they rock stages as late night host Jimmy Fallon’s house band (and manage to lose not one ounce of hip-hop credibility) AND put out incredibly dope albums, Thought’s been the band’s secret weapon behind ?uestlove’s unique look and outside personality. I think of him as the guy who comes to work with his lunchbox every day, puts in 8 hours of dependable, consistent hard work. Easy to overlook but no less valuable.
11. Eminem
Representing: Detroit
Greatest white rapper, ever-no question (I mean, who’d even come second? MC Serch? Paul Barman?). Extremely gifted. SO gifted, in fact, that like many of the emcees who appear above him on this list, the fact that he squanders them so often pisses me the hell off. In addition to the half-decade long period in the wilderness, his refusal to grow up and adjust his subject matter to reflect the fact that he’s almost 40 is what kept me from putting him in the Top Ten. Truthfully, Em’s a textbook example of someone whose skills are an A+ (I don’t think there’s any rapper that’s come out since him capable of rhyming so well from a technical standpoint) but whose recorded output (regardless of how many multi-millions he’s sold) is often lacking.
6 comments
Kyle says:
Jun 8, 2011
I’m going to say this before Other Kyle has a chance to…Brother Ali, Sage Francis and Eyedea can stand up to Em. No white rapper in the public’s eye can though. 🙂 Very happy you posted this, I’ll talk to you about it in person soon.
blerd says:
Jun 8, 2011
I disagree. I don’t know much about Eyedea, so I’ll give him a pass, but I’ve given Sage Francis and Brother Ali albums a listen and was completely unimpressed. Both good rhymers, but boring as hell.
Greg says:
Jun 10, 2011
In terms of sheer influence, no other white rapper trumps Eminem. That kinda goes without saying. However, Em isn’t exactly an untouchable pillar of white MCing—for lack of a better phrase. Eyedea’s music was kind of hit or miss for me, but he was one of the best technical rappers of his time—no question. Vinnie Paz can be just as crazy, cerebral and technical as Em when he really wants to be. Same thing with Cage, who’s “Hell’s Winter” beats the shit out of “The Marshall Mathers LP,” in my most humblest of opinions. Brother Ali is just on some next level shit all-together, and I stand by my belief that he’s the best rapper doing it right now. R.A. the Rugged Man has at least one great record in him, assuming that whole him-being-crazy-thing doesn’t keep him from realizing it (and even BIG was apparently wowed by his skill). Edan is one of the most insanely talented artists working today and has managed to keep up with guys like Percee P and Mr. Lif in the past, though he’s become kind of a reclusive bastard in the last few years. I’m sure somebody would argue that Ill Bill should be placed in the same company—I’m sure as fuck not gonna do it, but I’m _somebody_ would.
I’d also give a shout-out to El-P. He’s not exactly a lyrical heavyweight, but he can more than hold his own on the mic, especially for a producer. Besides, him, Kool Keith and the guys from De La Soul have influenced just about every alternative rapper that’s come out in the last decade and a half. Like seriously.
Also: where’s Vanilla Ice? Violent J? Kevin Federline? Snow? Donnie Wahlberg? Rapping Rodney? Fucking…Dee Dee Ramone?
Anyway, great list so far, Mike. Looking forward to the Top Ten.
blerd says:
Jun 10, 2011
Influence is certainly one thing that puts Eminem a few levels above other emcees of his ilk. I forgot about R.A. the Rugged Man-he’s dope. But I have to say, and this’ll just have to be one of those things, I don’t get the fascination with Brother Ali. At ALL.
Dayo says:
Jun 11, 2011
Man, you don’t get the fascination with Brother Ali, at all? Man, you trippin’! Nah, just kidding.
Just caught this series today. I’m really enjoying myself reading this series. I definitely hear you on Cee-Lo: a little underrated, in my opinion. And Em would have definitely ranked much higher if his execution was in damn line with his immense talent almost all the time!
Look forward to the next five!
The Top 40 Emcees of All Time: #10-#9 | Popblerd!! says:
Jun 14, 2011
[…] make sure you check out the rest of the list, with the most recent entrants posted here (you can backtrack through the entire list from […]